
I avoid writing cookbook reviews; to me, cookbooks are either "cool" or "useless" or they "totally blow." Pretty profound, huh? I do enjoy reading cookbooks - even those I never cook from; I read cookbooks in bed; I could spend entire days in bookstores browsing cookbooks. I really, really like food photography, but many of my favorite cookbooks have no pictures at all, maybe a drawing here and there.
So last week I picked up
Recipes From a Very Small Island by Linda and Martha Greenlaw - I like the book design, the recipe selection, and of course that it's a New England book. I think I bought it partly because it had a recipe for Geoff's favorite boat drink, the
Dark and Stormy (Gosling's rum and ginger beer). It also has what looks like a good recipe for
Braised Lamb Shanks with Dried Apricots and a recipe for
Molasses Cornbread that I can't wait to try. All in all, I think it was a good buy. I have two major criticisms however: misleading food photos. The first one occurs on page 22, accompanying the
Maine Shrimp Remoulade recipe.

Anyone who knows Maine shrimp can see that those pictured are NOT. Granted, the photo caption states:

What's wrong with the way Maine shrimp look? They are God's beautiful tasty creatures too, as seen in this photo on the
Maine Lobster Direct website:
Don't they look yummy?
The other image that really frosts my cupcake is on page 152 -

the
Braised Chicken with Garlic and Fennel. I'd like to think that I know braised meats. Does that look braised to you? Read this (abridged, take my word for it, no grilling occured, I just didn't feel like scanning the second page)
recipe and tell me how those grill marks got on there, when the chicken is supposed to be browned in a Dutch oven? This grilled chicken is garnished with thyme, not the fennel, garlic, carrots and potatoes it's supposed to be cooked with. It's insulting, is what it is. I can't understand why the Greenlaws obviously caved in to some skinny black turtleneck wearing "I-don't-eat-food-I-just-style-it" food stylist or photographer who said that the lovely, moist, braised chicken would look so much better with some charred bits on a dry plate. Where's the juice, I ask? Where's the caption "No, this is not braised chicken" on this pic?
I do like this cookbook, and will probably use it this very week. I forgive you, Martha and Linda, for succumbing to food stylist glamour.